The Folklore of Forever by Sarah Hogle
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
The Folklore of Forever is the 2nd-book in the Moonville series by Sarah Hogle. If I’m understanding it correctly, these are companion novels following various characters in the town of Moonville, Ohio.
The 1st-book, and this one, follow sisters, but I’m not sure if all the books are going to follow sisters in this family, who are maybe witches, or if other townsfolk will be included. Nevertheless, it includes many whimsical witchy vibes.
In this one, we’re following Zelda Tempest, a paranormal skeptic, and Morgan Angelopoulos, a ghost-hunting podcast host with a deep desire for magic.
Zelda’s family, the Tempests, include a history of alleged witches, including her two sisters, but Zelda doesn’t get down with all of that. Even though she’s made her living writing paranormal mystery books, she’s not a believer.
She’s recently returned to her hometown of Moonville with a case of writer’s block, hoping it will inspire her creativity in some way. It’s there she begins having run-ins with the handsome man next door, Morgan.
Morgan ends up convincing Zelda to go on one of his ghost-hunting romps with him, exploring a local haunted property, and it’s during this night out that Zelda discovers something disturbing about herself. She can see whimsical creatures lurking in the Moonville woods that no one else can see.
Maybe her sisters aren’t just faking it. Perhaps she has magical powers too? She and Morgan pair up and lean into Zelda’s creature spotting abilities, delving deep into Moonville’s woods to see what else could be hidden there.
This was such an oddly-composed book. I felt compelled to keep reading, but couldn’t really understand why?
It’s hard to explain. It’s not bad by any stretch, but yeah, definitely just a head-scratching, middle of road experience for me. It’s also a bit outside my comfort zone, as I don’t tend to vibe well with light-whimsical stories. I prefer a lot of dark, danger and dread with my whimsy.
Additionally, the story itself was ALL over the place. It was enchanting, but in a Luna Lovegood-when you first meet her-kind of way.
You wonder, is she okay? And of course, she is, she’s great, but at times hard to understand.
The writing style is eccentric, and both the character interactions and the plot felt chaotic. With this being said though, I did enjoy watching the relationship between Zelda and Morgan develop.
While it was certainly the oddest Romance book I’ve ever read, I think for people who enjoy this type of story, especially the Cottagecore vibes, this could work quite well.
It does get really wild towards the end. I was laughing out loud, like it really got that wild. It was fun though. I certainly never could have predicted all that happened.
I am interested, believe it or not, in picking up the other books in this series. As oddly compelling as it is, I want to get the other sister’s stories as well.
Thank you to the publisher, G.P. Putnam’s Sons, for providing me with a copy to read and review. Even though a little out of my element, I still enjoyed my time with this.