A Voice in the Dark by Barbara Nickless
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
**3.5-stars rounded up**
A Voice in the Dark is the 1st-book in the Benedict Hoffman and Helen Belle series from Barbara Nickless. This is an Adult Crime Mystery series that follows FBI Profilers.
Where my brain goes when I hear Criminal Profiler:

This book kicks off when a father, mother and son are killed in their Boulder, Colorado home. That same night, the family’s teenage twins disappear. Helen Belle is intrigued by the case as it mirrors one she worked on 5-year ago, where a boy killed his whole family and then went mute.
That case led Helen to a mysterious online figure known as the Midnight Man. That this figure may have played a role in that case, perhaps urging the boy to commit his terrible crimes, has never left Helen’s mind, but she and her partner on the case, Benedict, weren’t able to prove anything.

With this new case, and the clues that come along with it, Helen can’t shake the feeling that this confirms what she and Benedict were saying before. There is someone out there influencing these kids to commit horrific crimes, and this person needs to be flushed out and stopped.
Even though she and Benedict didn’t part under the best of terms, Helen reaches out to him with the details of the new case, to see if he’ll help her try to stop the Midnight Man once and for all.

Honestly, I had my ups-and-downs with this one. In the beginning, I saw it as a solid 3-star read, but the 2nd-half did pick up considerably for me and I loved the direction the author ultimately went with it. It felt very modern.
One thing I felt, particularly towards the beginning, was that I wished we were just getting Helen’s perspective, as opposed to getting both Helen and Benedict. I didn’t really care for Benedict. His personality just wasn’t appealing to me in the slightest.
However, by the end, he has started to grow on me. I’m still not completely sold on him yet, but we’ll see how we get on in the future installments.

I did appreciate how gruesome Nickless went with her details. She didn’t really hold much back, and I like that. I want to be uncomfortable. I want to be gripped, and the case in this story definitely had my attention. The twins that disappeared, particularly, Katelynn, I was worried for them and wanted them to be okay.
Overall, while I did feel like Benedict’s sections did slow down the pace of this one for me, it ended up being a fairly solid story. I will definitely be continuing with the series. I feel like it’ll only get stronger as it goes, and as I become more attached to the characters.
Even you, Benedict.

Thank you to the publisher, Thomas & Mercer, for providing me with a copy to read and review. I’m looking forward to reading more from this author.
A Voice in the Dark will be available on July 1, 2026.












































