Look What the Cat Dragged In by Jason Rekulak
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Look What the Cat Dragged In follows a successful young illustrator, Penny Padget, who has a series inspired by her beloved cat, Popcorn. She’s under-pressure to crank out the 4th-installment when Popcorn goes missing, via an open window, in a horrendous snowstorm.
Penny immediately rallies the troops, aka. her friends, but in spite of leaving no stone unturned, they’re unable to locate Popcorn. In the aftermath, Penny is obviously devastated. How can she move forward with her sweet angel, her best friend, her muse, Popcorn, missing?
Penny’s boyfriend, Dean, who she lives with, tries everything to cheer her up, but nothing seems to work. Nevertheless, he persists and wants to return to their normal life. He ends up talking her into joining him for a very lavish work event set at a private estate.
It’s there that Penny meets, Godfrey, a opinionated male cat who takes an instant liking to her. Seeing how Godfrey has literally attached himself to Penny, Godfrey’s owner implores Penny to cat-sit for her while she travels overseas. After a brief discussion, Penny reluctantly agrees.
Not long after Godfrey enters their home, things begin to change, and not in a good way. Penny is losing time, hearing things and having disturbing nightmares. Godfrey’s behavior has also changed. He’s gone from attentive and affectionate to downright creepy and stalkerish.
Dean is zero help. Penny has a hard time explaining all the things that are happening whilst he’s away at work, but even when she does, he brushes off her concerns. Then her health begins to fail. She’s being changed. It’s like she’s under attack by some malevolent force.
We follow Penny as she desperately tries to get to the bottom of what is happening in their house, and to her. She’s in a tough spot, with unbelievable claims. Will anyone be able to help her escape her dire circumstances?
I had an absolute blast with this book. I found it so utterly compelling and entertaining. It’s fun and wacky AF, and just so creative and satisfying. If I had to comp it, I would describe it as Black Sheep meets Rosemary’s Baby, with CATS!
The audiobook is fantastic. The stellar narration of Stephanie Németh-Parker truly brings Penny’s character to life. I felt like her delivery was spot on for what Penny might have been feeling in certain moments. It just made the story so engaging for me.
I highly recommend the audiobook format if you can get it.
I loved how Rekulak presented the more occult elements as well. It had a richly-dark humor to it that I found so fun. I know a lot of people don’t like horror and humor mixed, but for me, it’s one of my favorite combinations.
I’m a spooky-ooky, horror-loving girlie, but I also like having laughs with my stories. Sure, there’s a time and place. If you have a grief-focused Horror novel, I wouldn’t pepper in TOO much humor, but with a story like this, absolutely. Bring it on. I think Rekulak did a great job balancing the creepiness with the lighter, entertaining bits.
And for the most part, the humor for me was just Penny’s thoughts; her dry delivery of all the things happening. It was wild, and like, if you didn’t laugh, you’d cry, you know?
I think this is my favorite novel from Rekulak thus far. It checked off so many of the things I look for when searching for a story like this. I wouldn’t say it was perfect, but I didn’t really need it to be. I still had an amazing time with it and I can’t wait to get a hard copy for my collection.
Thank you so much to the publisher, Macmillan Audio, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This has cemented Rekulak as a must-read author for me. I cannot wait for whatever is next!