About a month ago, I received an ARC of the second book in the Shana Merchant series, The Dead Season, from Berkley Books. It is currently set to release on December 8, 2020.
Thank you so much for providing me with a copy, Berkley!
Although, I believe, like many Adult Mystery series, the books can be read as standalones, and do not necessarily need to be read in order, I still wanted to give this one a shot.
Upon completion, I am so happy that I did!
Shana Merchant is a veteran police detective, recently moved from the NYPD to a department in a quiet town in the Thousand Lakes region of Upstate New York.
She needed to get out of the city after a horrific incident involving a serial killer, so when her fiance suggested moving back to his hometown, she readily agreed.
Shana believes that with her move to a smaller community, she’ll be dealing with a lot less violent crime and may have an easier time coping with her return to work. Statistically she is correct.
When Shana and her new partner, Tim Wellington, get called to a private island to investigate a missing person case, however, Shana feels those old anxieties beginning to rise.
The island is owned by the wealthy Sinclair family, who made their fortune in American textiles.
Many members of the family happen to be on the island for the weekend when Jasper Sinclair goes missing in the middle of the night. Not only does he go missing, the bed he was sleeping in is drenched in blood.
It’s clear to Shana and Tim that Jasper has not left the property of his own volition, but how would he leave the property? It’s an island and all boats are accounted for?
When a vicious storm hits, Shana and Tim become stranded as well, and all remaining are now suspects.
This is a classically arranged locked-room mystery, a la Agatha Christie. As many of you may already know, this is my absolute favorite mystery trope.
I was swept up in the story from the very start and was actually surprised by how much I enjoyed this.
The Sinclair family, from the matriarch, all the way down to the youngest among them, felt completely real and each distinct in their own way.
I loved the toxic family dynamics and watching all their dirty little secrets come to light.
The pacing was fantastic to keep me intrigued the entire way through.
Although I felt a little let down by the actual whodunit; I can’t really explain why, I was just hoping it was a bit more devious than it ended up being, I genuinely enjoyed my time with this novel.
I really like Shana as a protagonist. She is quite a complex character and I cannot wait to find out more about her in the next novel.
This one left off at a fantastic spot as far as a lead in to a sequel. I am truly chomping at the bit to get into the next installment.
If you enjoy a taut, locked-room mystery with heavy Christie vibes, you should absolutely check out the Shana Merchant series!!!